humanespot.org humanespot.org humanespot.org
 
 

The Conceptual Separation of Food and Animals in Childhood

 
| | | | | | |
by
More Information...

Short Description:
This research examines the relationship between animals in literature and films versus those in promotional food tie-ins and how these relationships affect children and their ability to emotionally separate themselves from animals they consume.

Abstract:
Article Abstract:

"Nonhuman animals are primarily defined according to their form of relation with human beings, which broadly depends on the perceived utility of those animals to humans. These relations may be analyzed to generate typologies, membership of which circumscribes the probable fate of nonhuman animals when they enter into contact with humans. However, these judgments of utility and category membership are contingent and socially constructed, as demonstrated by cultural and historical variability in the species and individual animals assigned to particular types. This paper explores how the combination of childhood literary and film traditions relating to animals and associated promotional food tie-ins aimed at children contribute to a food socialization process whereby children learn to conceptually distance the animals they eat from those with whom they have an emotional bond or for whom they feel ethically responsible. In so doing, we develop a theoretical scheme for the differentiated positioning of animals."

Spot Check Number: 1709
Sponsor: University of Bristol
Researcher/Author: Kate Stewart, Matthew Cole
Animal Type: Various
Record Type: Academic Paper, Survey Summary
Research Method: Literature Review
Geographic Region: International
Number of Participants: Unknown
Population Descriptors: Children
Year Conducted: 2009
File Attachments: You must be logged in to access attachments (see login and registration links above)

Responses

Thank you everyone for the responses to this enlightening study. Thanks especially to the folks at FreeFromHarm.org for the excellent write-up! (see http://bit.ly/mB5dzG). For those interested in the full study... As a small nonprofit organization, the Humane Research Council is not able to provide access to full research articles when those articles require a fee from the source, in this case the journal "Food, Culture and Society." However, I recommend contacting one of the study's authors to request the full study. For instance, Matthew Cole. His contact information can be found here: http://vegatopia.org/contact.html

Need access

How can I access this paper? I recently registered on humanepost.org.

my translation

Do children have an inherent sense of right and wrong even before we tell them anything about morality? That's the profound question I was left to ponder after a neighbor's 3-year-old child came to visit my hens and professed to me with proud intention ""I don't eat chicken because I don't want them to die for us," he said. This came just days after I discovered this most fascinating paper about how we teach children a separate morality for farm animals through popular culture, advertising, film and literature. It's an eye-opening read, definitely the most important discovery I've made this month. In fact it was so inspiring I felt like I had to take this slice of academia and translate it into a vernacular that more people could connect to. And that's how I ended up with my feature story for this month, "How We Teach Children a Separate Morality for Food Animals." I guess what amazed me about this 3-year old's statement was that, unlike many of the adults I've talked to, he seemed to understand implicitly that the taking of a life was more important than our selfish preoccupations about what foods we like and dislike.

Counterbalancing the effects of speciesism

As parents, teachers, and caregivers, we need to counter the messages in mainstream media by choosing books and movies that affirm vegetarian and vegan values. A couple of my favorite picks are Granny Gomez & Jigsaw by Deborah Underwood, and Garlic- Onion- Beet- Spinach- Mango- Carrot- Grapefruit Juice by Nathalie VanBalen.

What a fascinating study!

What a fascinating study! Thank you for uncovering this!

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.


PLEASE SUPPORT NONPROFIT RESEARCH FOR ANIMALS

Did you find this research helpful in your work for animals? If so, please consider a donation to the Humane Research Council to help us with the costs of maintaining, expanding, and improving HumaneSpot.org.